Twitter fined $546,000 in December 2020 by European Data Protection Authority for 2019 Breach Notification Violations

Posted on January 5, 2021 by BeAware4lways

The Irish Data Protection Commission (DPC) fined Twitter 450,000 euros (about US$546,000) for failing to timely notify the Irish DPC within the required 72 hours of discovering a Q4 2018 breach involving a bug in its Android app, and also for failing to adequately document that breach. The bug caused some 88,726 European Twitter users’ protected tweets to be made public.

The case is notable because it is the first fine levied against a U.S. technology company in a cross border violation under the EU’s General Data Protection Regulation’s (GDPR), which went into effect in 2018. Under the GDPR, the member state of the foreign company’s EU headquarters takes the lead on inquiries on behalf of all the EU’s 27 member states. Because Twitter EU’s headquarters are in Ireland, the DPC took the lead on the investigating the 2018 breach incident, which Twitter attributed to poor staffing during the holidays.

Pursuant to Article 60 of the GDPR, the Irish DPC submitted its draft decision last May to the other EU DPAs. In the draft decision, the Irish DPC found Twitter’s violations to be negligent, but not intentional or systematic. Other member states disagreed with the Irish DPC draft decision, due in part to the small proposed fine. The Irish DPC‘s proposed fine was only a small fraction of the maximum fine amount permitted, which under GDPR is up to 4% of a company’s global revenue or 20 million euros ($22 million), whichever is higher. Twitter’s global annual revenue was reportedly about $60 million in 2018.

The Irish DPC responded to the criticisms from other member states by stating that its proposed fine under the GDPR was an “effective, proportionate and dissuasive measure” and brought the matter before the European Data Protection Board, which upheld most of the decision but directed Ireland to increase the fine.

The Twitter case is just the first of many cases involving U.S. companies before the Irish DPC, as there are some 20 other pending inquiries. Ireland also serves as the EU headquarters for U.S. technology companies such as Facebook, Apple and Google.

The decision is available here.

Privacy Tip #258 – Misinformation on Social Media

Posted on November 5, 2020 by BeAware4lways

The misinformation on social media about the election results (and other topics) is rampant. Social media companies like Twitter and Facebook are struggling with the balance between the First Amendment right to free speech and false information or exaggerated reports on their platforms and are hiding or flagging those they deem to be false or misleading.

Misinformation and false information does not help anyone get to the truth. Getting news from reliable sources and news outlets, instead of through social media platforms and websites, is usually more reliable because there are standards in the news industry that must be followed by major news organizations regarding content.

In addition, going to unreliable websites to obtain information may put you at a higher risk of a cyber-attack. Cyber criminals and foreign adversaries develop fake websites and when individuals click on such a website, they introduce malware or ransomware into the system.

Don’t be fooled by false or misleading information on social media platforms or websites. Go directly to the source to stay informed and to stay cyber-safe.

New York Department of Financial Services Issues Report on Recent Twitter Hack

Posted on October 22, 2020 by BeAware4lways

You probably heard about the recent hack of Twitter accounts that took place on July 15, 2020. The hackers took over several prominent Twitter accounts, which resulted in a scam that netted over $118,000 in bitcoin for the hackers. One of the most startling things about the cyberattack was that it was led by a 17-year-old along with his accomplices. The hackers took over the accounts of well-known individuals including Barack Obama, Kim Kardashian West, Kanye West, Bill Gates, Elon Musk and many others, and tweeted a “double your bitcoin scam” from these Twitter accounts directing people to send bitcoin to fraudulent accounts.

The New York Department of Financial Services (NYDFS) issued a detailed report last week regarding this hack into the social media giant. The report found that “the Twitter Hack happened in three phases: (1) social engineering attacks to gain access to Twitter’s network; (2) taking over accounts with desirable usernames (or “handles”) and selling access to them; and (3) taking over dozens of high-profile Twitter accounts and trying to trick people into sending the Hackers bitcoin. All this happened in roughly 24 hours.”

How did the hackers do it? According to the report, the first phase of the attack started with the hackers stealing credentials of Twitter employees the old-fashioned way by using social engineering. The hackers posed as Twitter IT employees and contacted several Twitter employees claiming there was a problem with Twitter’s Virtual Private Network (VPN). The report stated that the “hackers claimed they were responding to a reported problem the employee was having with Twitter’s Virtual Private Network (VPN). Since switching to remote working, VPN problems were common at Twitter. The Hackers then tried to direct the employee to a phishing website that looked identical to the legitimate Twitter VPN website and was hosted by a similarly named domain. As the employee entered their credentials into the phishing website, the Hackers would simultaneously enter the information into the real Twitter website. This false log-in generated an MFA [multi-factor authentication] notification requesting that the employees authenticate themselves, which some of the employees did.”

The hackers then went surfing within the Twitter system looking for employees with access to internal tools to take over accounts. This led to the second phase of the attack: taking over and selling access to original gangster (OG) Twitter accounts. According to the report, an OG Twitter account refers to accounts designated by a single word, letter, or number and adopted by Twitter’s early users. The hackers discussed taking over and selling the OG accounts in various online chat messages. On July 15, the hackers “ hijacked multiple OG Twitter accounts and tweeted screenshots of one of the internal tools from some of the accounts to the accounts’ respective followers.

The final phase of the hack involved taking over various cryptocurrency company accounts and directing users to a link to a scam bitcoin address. According to a tweet sent out by Twitter on July 16, approximately 130 accounts of high-profile verified users (those Twitter accounts that you see with the blue check mark) were taken over by the hackers with tweets asking people to send bitcoin, with the promise that the high-profile user would double the amount to be given to a charity. The bitcoin address was fraudulent, the tweets were not sent by the actual users, and the hackers were able to collect more than $118,000 in bitcoin.

The NYDFS began its investigation because the cryptocurrency companies are regulated entities. According to the report, the department instructed the cryptocurrency companies to block the hackers’ bitcoin addresses if they hadn’t already done so. This move prevented over a million dollars’ worth of fraudulent bitcoin transfers.

We write all the time about the critical importance of cybersecurity practices and protocols such as multifactor authentication, employee training regarding phishing, and using secure passwords. The general consensus appears to be that the Twitter hack was not a sophisticated one, but that the hackers knew what they were after and knew how to accomplish their goal. The NYDFS report stated that “the Twitter Hack is a cautionary tale about the extraordinary damage that can be caused even by unsophisticated cybercriminals. The Hackers’ success was due in large part to weaknesses in Twitter’s internal cybersecurity protocols.”