A serious security flaw in a commonly used, but overlooked open source security module may be undermining the integrity of hundreds of thousands or even millions of private and public applications, putting untold numbers of organizations and data at risk.
A team of independent security researchers that includes application security professionals at Shutterstock and Squarespace identified the flaw in private-ip, a npm module first published in 2016 that enables applications to block request forgery attacks by filtering out attempts to access private IP4 addresses and other restricted IP4 address ranges, as defined by ARIN
The SSRF Blocker That Didn’t
The researchers identified a so-called Server Side Request Forgery (SSRF) vulnerability in commonly used versions of private-ip. The flaw allows malicious attackers to carry out SSRF attacks against a population of applications that may number in the hundreds of thousands or millions globally. It is just the latest incident to raise questions about the security of the “software supply chain,” as more and more organizations shift from monolithic to modular software application development built on a foundation of free and open source code.
According to an account by researcher John Jackson of Shutterstock, flaws in the private-ip code meant that the filtering allegedly carried out by the code was faulty. Specifically, independent security researchers reported being able to bypass protections and carry out Server-Side Request Forgeries against top tier applications. Further investigation uncovered a common explanation for those successful attacks: private-ip, an open source security module used by the compromised applications.
SSRF attacks allow malicious actors to abuse functionality on a server: reading data from internal resources or modifying the code running on the server. Private-ip was created to help application developers spot and block such attacks. SSRF is one of the most common forms of attack on web applications according to OWASP.
The problem: private-ip didn’t do its job very well.
“The code logic was using a simple Regular Expression matching,” Jackson (@johnjhacking) told The Security Ledger. Jackson, working with other researchers, found that private-ip was blind to a wide number of variations of localhost, and other private-ip ranges as well as simple tricks that hackers use to obfuscate IP addresses in attacks. For example, researchers found they could send successful requests for localhost resources by obscuring those addresses using hexadecimal equivalents of private IP addresses or with simple substitutions like using four zeros for each octet of the IP address instead of one (so: 0000.0000.0000.0000 instead of 0.0.0.0). The result: a wide range of private and restricted IP addresses registered as public IP addresses and slipped past private-ip.
Private-IP: small program, BIG footprint
The scope of the private-ip flaws are difficult to grasp. However, available data suggests the component is very widely used. Jackson said that hundreds of thousands, if not millions of applications likely incorporate private-ip code in some fashion. Many of those applications are not publicly addressable from the Internet, but may still be vulnerable to attack by an adversary with access to their local environment.
Private-ip is the creation of developer Damir Mustafin (aka “frenchbread”), a developer based in the Balkan country of Montenegro, according to his GitHub profile, which contains close to 60 projects of different scopes. Despite its popularity and widespread use, private-ip was not a frequent focus of Mr. Mustafin’s attention. After first being published in August 2016, the application had only been updated once, in April 2017, prior to the most recent update to address the SSRF flaw.
A Low Key, High Distribution App
The lack of steady attention didn’t dissuade other developers from downloading and using the npm private-ip package, however. It has an average of 14,000 downloads weekly, according to data from GitHub. And direct downloads of private-ip are just one measure of its use. Fully 355 publicly identified npm modules are dependents of private-ip v1.0.5, which contains the SSRF flaws. An additional 73 GitHub projects have dependencies on private-ip. All told, that accounts for 153,374 combined weekly downloads of private-ip and its dependents. One of the most widely used applications that relies on private-ip is libp2p, an open source network stack that is used in a wide range of decentralized peer-to-peer applications, according to Jackson.
While the flaw was discovered by so-called “white hat” vulnerability researchers, Jackson said that it is almost certain that malicious actors knew about and exploited it -either directly or inadvertently. Other security researchers have almost certainly stumbled upon it before as well, perhaps discovering a single address that slipped through private-ip and enabled a SSRF attack, while failing to grasp private-ip’s role or the bigger flaws in the module.
In fact, private-ip may be the common source of a long list of SSRF vulnerabilities that have been independently discovered and reported in the last five years, Jackson said.”This may be why a lot of enterprises have struggled with SSRF and block list bypasses,” he said.
After identifying the problem, Jackson and his team contacted the developer, Damir Mustafin (aka “frenchbread”), looking for a fix. However, it quickly became clear that they would need to enlist additional development talent to forge a patch that was comprehensive. Jackson tapped two developers: Nick Sahler of the website hosting provider Square Space and the independent developer known as Sick Codes (@sickcodes) to come up with a comprehensive fix for private-ip. The two implemented the netmask utility and update private-ip to correctly filter private IP ranges and translate all submitted IP addresses at the byte level to catch efforts to slip encoded addresses past the filter.
Common Mode Failures and Software Supply Chain
Even though it is fixed, the private-ip flaw raises larger and deeply troubling questions about the security of software applications on which our homes, businesses and economy are increasingly dependent.
The greater reliance on open source components and the shift to agile development and modular applications has greatly increased society’s exposure to so-called “common cause” failures, in which a the failure of a single element leads to a systemic failure. Security experts say the increasingly byzantine ecosystem of open source and proprietary software with scores or hundreds of poorly understood ‘dependencies’ is ripe for such disruptions.
Less scrutinized is low quality code and applications that may quickly be adopted and woven into scores or hundreds or thousands of other applications and components.
“The problem with (software) dependencies is once you identify a problem with a dependency, everything downstream is f**ked,” the developer known as Sick Codes told The Security Ledger. “It’s a house of cards.”
In the short term, organizations that know they are using private-ip version 1.0.5 or earlier as a means of preventing SSRF or related vulnerabilities should upgrade to the latest version immediately, Jackson said. Static application security testing tools can help identify whether private-ip is in use within your organization.
The bigger fix is for application developers to pay more attention to what they’re putting into their creations. “My recommendations is that when software engineers use packages in general or third party code, they need to evaluate what they’re using and where its coming from,” Jackson said.